The September 14 clash between India and Pakistan not only made headlines for on-field action but also for an unusual controversy — players refusing to shake hands. Initially, the PCB accused match referee Andy Pycroft of stopping both teams from the customary handshake. However, fresh revelations show the truth lies elsewhere.

According to reports, Pycroft was merely following instructions from the Asian Cricket Council (ACC), which had directed that the captains of India and Pakistan should avoid handshakes during the toss. This disclosure takes the blame off Pycroft and shifts responsibility towards the ACC.

Mohsin Naqvi in a tight spot
A Times of India report states that the PCB had complained to the ICC on September 15, alleging Pycroft had violated the Code of Conduct. The ICC investigated and responded, confirming that Pycroft acted strictly as instructed and committed no breach. The ICC even praised him for handling the situation tactfully, avoiding any embarrassment on live television.

What makes the situation more awkward for Pakistan is that ACC President is none other than PCB chief Mohsin Naqvi himself. If the order came from the ACC, the PCB’s own chairman indirectly bears responsibility.

PCB’s repeated emails
Unsatisfied with the ICC’s clarification, the PCB threatened to pull out of the Asia Cup unless Pycroft was removed. The ICC refused, stating that no official could be replaced at a team’s demand. Despite this, the PCB sent another email on September 17, again alleging code violations, but has not provided evidence so far.

The UAE match drama
Ahead of their September 17 fixture against the UAE, Pakistan delayed leaving their hotel, escalating tensions further. Eventually, Pycroft held a meeting with captain Salman Agha, manager Navid Akram Cheema, and coach Mike Hesson to clear misunderstandings. While the PCB claimed Pycroft apologized, reports insist no apology was made. A muted video from the meeting has since gone viral, fueling the debate.